Byakugan vs Sharingan

[Shakaku]

Byakugan or Sharingan which is stronger?

[BakaSama]

I'd say sharingan has the better battle options

[Kagutsuchi]

sharingan from what we've seen so far, but we havent seen all of byakugan's true powers...yet

MS is just overkill

[Spell]

Sharingan, it's abilities are way better than Byakugan's.

[Jonas]

It's a question of style. And this has been done to death, can some mod please fuse this thread with the old one (i know there is one).

By the way, read the last comment in my sig.

[Hyuuga Neji]

byakugan. let aside copying jutsus vs jyuken, the byakugan can do everything the sharingan can only it can do it better

and stopping people from using any jutsu with the most deadly hand to hand style is better than copying and using twice before exausting.....

sharigan is way too overrated.

[Sharikagen]

it matters what you look for... IMO byukagen is more taijutsu than anything because you can see and stop chakra flow by using a unique taijutsu stylu(jyuken) which is a byuukagen technique, not to include being able to have an absolute defense.. Byuakagen is nice because not only does it give you an already great offense but a near-unbeatable defense, because it can see 360 degrees, you can see greater distances, and you have an absolute defense.. The only thing it lacks is a good ninjitsu/genjitsu ability or better technique in the field, yet even kakashi has said that in terms of insight the byukagen surpasses even his own sharigan, which i dont know if he means the sharigan in basic or his...

Sharigan on the other side gives the user a real upper hand advantage.. as seen in the kakashi/zabuza fight pt.1 if you have good enough control with the sharigan you can instantly match your opponent which is nice.. Not only that you can copy nearly every jutsu you see.. So the sharigan can let you copy taijutsu(as seen by sasuke), ninjitsu(seen by kakashi), your a genius, and you can easly get the upper hand in a battle since once the sharigan is activated you can predict the oppenents attack or movements to predict when to move, yet like in the lee/sasuke fight if your body cant keep up with your eyes your kinda screwed, and you can pretty much hypnotize or encourage thoughts in people that arent extremely powerful..
Now another nice thing of the sharigan is the Mangekyou Sharingan. With the MS you get two extremely powerful jutsu's Tsukuyomi and Amaterasu.. even though a friend sacrafice is needed for the MS it definetly gives you a edge..

[Hyuuga Neji]

MS seems like too high a cost.

its rare even in the people who have sharingan

overuse means you are screwed for a week

gotta kill your best friend

or is it? i mean the jutsus are still damn strong. i still think the best hand-to-hand style in konoha is a better advantage

[Genis-Vell]

Byakugan vs Sharingan
Oh not this again (slowly starts to back away from the thread)

Way to many fanboys, hardheaded fanboys I might add. And to much ego to go with the fanboysim (I guess they think since they read the manga, and watch the anime that makes them the most absolute hardcore, most knowledgeable person regarding Naruto in general.)


But my own personal opinion.

White eyes don’t have the bad side effects the way Shringa seems to come with. (You keep your eye vision, and it dosnt seem to draw to much charka like Sharingan does.)

Sharingan but sharing an can go several levels higher, and access some wicked abilities, and perform some of the most powerful Jutsus.

But I favor White eyes. If I could chose for myself Id go with White eyes.

[jemakai]

Sharingan is the better battle eye, I would think this is obvious since it helps in all area's of jutsu and allows prediction.
Byukgan is the better non-battle eye since you can use it for recon and information gathering. It depends on what you want to do. Personally I would rather hypnotis people and see the future then see their insides and all directions.

[Chamcham Trigger]

Done before....wow before I even joined actually. I say neither is the stronger at the moment. Each limit has shown really good strengths and weaknesses to using those strengths, so I can't come to a conclusion as of yet.

[Uzumaki Yondaime]

The sharingan is definately better because it offers a lot more things than the Byakugan can offer its user.

[itachiunleashed]

Def. sharingan. cmon! MS sharingan sends bastards into a different fricken demension and compresses 3 days into 5 seconds!!!!!!!!!!! beat that byakugan!!!

[K I S K E]

Byukagan. I like it more, and it makes you look like a bad ass.

[Ikari Shinji]

Byakugan > 3 tomoe Sharingan
MS > Byakugan

[Hyuuga Neji]

byakugan is non-battle? but juuken is the most deadly hand-to-hand style in konoha

oh and the byakugan can also predict the same way the sharingan can only it can do it on a longer range. however, sharingan can copy many jutsus leaving a lot of possibilities open

[jemakai]

byakugan is non-battle? but juuken is the most deadly hand-to-hand style in konoha

oh and the byakugan can also predict the same way the sharingan can only it can do it on a longer range. however, sharingan can copy many jutsus leaving a lot of possibilities open

Compared to each other, sharingan is obviously the better battle eye. Hell, you can only evolve it in the middle of battle. Sharingan by itself can defeat its opponents just by looking at their eye's, Byukgan does not have any abilities that hurt opponents only support the users abilities while the sharingan does that and more.

Byukgan better then 3 tomoe sharingan? Ha! So I guess Hinata's eyes are better then Itachi's! Byukagan requires training for better sight and abilities, sharingan grants better abilities with up grades without training and even more abilities with training.
No it can not, Byukagan has never been shown to be able to predict opponents movements. In a Byukagan's vision all attacks become clear thus it gives them more time to react to attacks, this isn't the same as actually seeing future movements. Sharingan is far more specific in that regard.

[Fubar]

Id say they both have their advantages. I would pick MS sharingan otherwise I would say Byakugan. Im paranoid though and don't like people being behind me so I guess thats my own personal bias. If I was to "drop the soap" I would definately prefer Byakugan.

Being able to see tenketsus and cut off someones chakra flow completely = invaluable. Besides Kakashi says its much more powerful so I'm with him.

[LorD GothmoG]

It depends on your style, and we haven't seen all abilites of byakugan...but mayby thre are no other powers of it? Sharingan gives very big advantage in battle and it gaves ability to use genjutsu on high level(even if it's not MS), so I say sharingan however I prefere white eye and Huugas than sharingan and Uchichas:P

[Loud Mouth]

I like the Byakugan more but this isn't really a question that can be answered. Maybe which is better for a particular situation...

But both limits are designed to suit the user perfectly... give Sasuke the Byakugan and Neji the Sharingan and they'd probably be wasted.

[Son Goku]

Byakugan . yeah i chose it because the sharigan is a branch of the byakugan

[Hyuuga Neji]

Compared to each other, sharingan is obviously the better battle eye. Hell, you can only evolve it in the middle of battle. Sharingan by itself can defeat its opponents just by looking at their eye's, Byukgan does not have any abilities that hurt opponents only support the users abilities while the sharingan does that and more.

Byukgan better then 3 tomoe sharingan? Ha! So I guess Hinata's eyes are better then Itachi's! Byukagan requires training for better sight and abilities, sharingan grants better abilities with up grades without training and even more abilities with training.
No it can not, Byukagan has never been shown to be able to predict opponents movements. In a Byukagan's vision all attacks become clear thus it gives them more time to react to attacks, this isn't the same as actually seeing future movements. Sharingan is far more specific in that regard.

just a few clarifying: you cant just defeat some1 by looking at them in the eye. you make them fall in your gengetsu by looking at them in the eye

byakugan can predict a move the minute it enters a 50 m range and this works for 360 degrees. sure sharingan can do it only byakugan can do it better.

also it was stated that in eye of insight (just insight, not all) the byakugan > sharingan. and eye of insight means many things, one being predicting movements

finally as sasuke uzumaki said, sharingan is just a branch off byakugan

acctually hinata's EYE OF INSIGHT is better than itachi's mainly because his eye sight is decaying. but her fighting skills totally suck compared to his

[Ikari Shinji]

just a few clarifying: you cant just defeat some1 by looking at them in the eye. you fall in they genjutsu if you look in their eye

byakugan can predict a move the minute it enters a 50 m range and this words for 360 degrees. sure sharingan can do it only byakugan can do it better.

also it was stated that in eye of insight (just insight, not all) the byakugan > sharingan. and eye of insight means many things, one being predicting movements

finally as sasuke uzumaki said, sharingan is just a branch off byakugan
Well the 50m thing applied to Neji pre-skip
Post-skip he can see up to 800m around

[Hyuuga Neji]

Well the 50m thing applied to Neji pre-skip
Post-skip he can see up to 800m around

when did they say that? i missed it......

[m.hyuga]

i will say right now the sharingan but we have seen about 3-4 techniques used by Neji they should show more of the abilities of the byakugan. The sharingan has the MS which is one of the most powerful jutsus out there we need to see so jutsu from the hyuga's will someone train neji for gods sake so this can be settled

[Hyuuga Neji]

people are not taking weaknesses into consideration!!

itachi is screwed if he keeps useing MS...... NOT GOOD!

[Sasori-Bot]

well, i would say byakugan due to the hyuuga fighting style, but if u manage to get MS, Sharingan would be better.

[Ikari Shinji]

when did they say that? i missed it......
Chapter 263, Neji spots one of the kin tags that is 800m away, he could be able to see at a greater distance but it hasn't been shown yet

[Hyuuga Neji]

found it yea i missed that for some retarded reason (usually i pay close attention to these parts)

they like to round things off so i wouldnt be surprised if he can see 1000 meters range

[makemytime]

i'm torn between choosing i mean they both hav very cool abilities

[TDM]

you cant just defeat some1 by looking at them in the eye.See Amaterasu. Even though I'm not buying the whole "temp of the Sun" bit at all, I'd like to see any normal nin just stand there and take a flame that burns for 7 days or something.

Anyway, it depends on what circumstance. When paired with the Hyuuga fighting style, I'll go with the Byakugan. If they went head to head, well, think about it this way.

Byakugan gives you 360 view. You kind of don't want a 360 view when you're trying to AVOID the dude's eyes.

[Hyuuga Neji]

that wasnt what he ment. he was refering to just looking into itachi's eyes when they didnt have MS on for example. well in that case you're in a gengetsu and not defeated or dead. but otherwise i see what you meen

[The_Leader]

Sharingan has veritable prediction.

Byakugan does NOT.

Insight is NOT precog, it'll give you insight into feelings and chakra system, but it WON'T predict movement for you.

Three tomoe sharingan>byakugan in taijutsu and just about everything else except for the 360 view.

It helps Neji that he's so good at taijutsu, but he still can't predict moves like a sharingan could.

[jemakai]

just a few clarifying: you cant just defeat some1 by looking at them in the eye. you make them fall in your gengetsu by looking at them in the eye

At high levels you can indeed defeat people by casting genjutsu on them through your eye's, especially normal people who you can just force to sleep.


byakugan can predict a move the minute it enters a 50 m range and this works for 360 degrees. sure sharingan can do it only byakugan can do it better.

That isn't prediction, that is anticipation. If the attack changed direction the Byukgan user would be as surprised as anyone else, but the sharingan user would have already seen the change and could have reacted to it before the change even occured.



also it was stated that in eye of insight (just insight, not all) the byakugan > sharingan. and eye of insight means many things, one being predicting movements

Yeah, and in this case insight simply means you can't fool Byukgan because of the 360 vision and x-ray vision. Forsight would be predictiong movements.


finally as sasuke uzumaki said, sharingan is just a branch off byakugan

Just like Byukgan is a branch of a regular eye. I don't see your point.

acctually hinata's EYE OF INSIGHT is better than itachi's mainly because his eye sight is decaying. but her fighting skills totally suck compared to his

I would still say his eye's currently are better then Hinata's.

[Mousuke]

Byakugan. Sure, MS is scary, but we've hardly even touched the surface of what the Byakugan has to offer.
And didn't they mention somewhere that the Uchiha's came from the Hyuugas? Does that make the Sharingan more or less advanced?
In any case, the Byakugan's abilities are pretty trippy

[Hyuuga Neji]

At high levels you can indeed defeat people by casting genjutsu on them through your eye's, especially normal people who you can just force to sleep.

well that is still different than just defeat. someone could still dispell it


That isn't prediction, that is anticipation. If the attack changed direction the Byukgan user would be as surprised as anyone else, but the sharingan user would have already seen the change and could have reacted to it before the change even occured.

what are you talking about? i dont remember neji being surprised by anything the way you describe it. he was hit by naruto when his byakugan was inactive. as for against kidoumaru, it got in his blind spot.


Yeah, and in this case insight simply means you can't fool Byukgan because of the 360 vision and x-ray vision. Forsight would be predictiong movements..

1st of all you just contradicted yourself, you said that you could surprise a byakugan user but now you say you cant fool them? :huh

then, tell me when they said the sharingan had the eye of forsight. kakashi said that the eye of insight GREATLY exeeds the sharingan. in that case i am assumeing he is comparing it to his sharingan (which was a three tomoe sharingan). now, the sharingan has the eye of insight. and here is the definition of insight:

in·sight (nst)
n.

Understanding, especially an understanding of the motives and reasons behind one's actions.

applied to those eyes, the byakugan and the sharingan can both see how a jutsu is being used and know how to avoid it. only byakugan can do it better


Just like Byukgan is a branch of a regular eye. I don't see your point..

it means that the abilities of sharingan come from the byakugan. they have only been modified so instead of being able to use the most deadly hand to hand style, sharingan can copy jutsus and use them at a much higher chakra cost.


I would still say his eye's currently are better then Hinata's.

id rather not start a whole argument on that


Three tomoe sharingan>byakugan in taijutsu and just about everything else except for the 360 view.

acctually no, they stated that juuken was the most deadly hand to hand style in konoha. besides a sharingan can only see in a normal field of vision, he cant see something he isnt looking at and he definatly cant predict it.