G Gundam or Gundam Wing?

[NinjutsuRedPanda]

Which is better? even though I love them both...you know...I couldn't make up my mind which was better.

[Mindless]

Hm... I can't really decide myself.

G Gundam with it's unique, but strange concept, or Gundam Wing with it's hypocritical and shallow characters...

I think my vote is on G Gundam. :)

[NinjutsuRedPanda]

Yeah...I'll go with G Gundam I guess. G Gundam isn't drawn AS well though. Yet, the movie Endless Waltz was lame. And G Gundam has great music.

[Hunter]

Well I personally enjoyed G-Gundam more than Wing.

[NinjutsuRedPanda]

True. But you can't help but to love both.

[Piekage]

I enjoyed both, but I'd go with G Gundam.

[Ha-ri]

G Gundam created a new level of suck, wing rules.

[Zeff]

I think Wing is much better

[darksage78]

Gundam Wing for sure. G Gundam was unique, but too unique for me. I cried when I looked up Canada Gundam... And what was up with the windmill gundam?

[Kiba-kun]

They were both pretty terrible, but I'd go with G Gundam.

[Jikes]

isn't G Gundam like the Gundam version of japanese Sentei(spelling?) shows? cuz if its is I believe I attempted to stab my eyes and ear drums when i saw burning gundam doing "GODO FINGA" in that Gundam Evolve episode.

should be called either Gudam Ball Z or Might Morphin Power Gundams.

I just kid I havn't seen the whole series so I can hardly judge.

[UltraSynaptic SeizureNinja]

I'd have to say Gundam Wing. Why? Because I really hate the design of Nobel Gundam.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y110/csolomon247901/gf13-050nsw.jpg

[Chillin]

I actually liked Gundam Wing. G Gundam had its moments, but I really didn't like it.

[Shadow Replication 1480]

I hated every single character in Wing aside from Duo and he's not enough to make me want to ever watch it again, so I'll go with G Gundam.

[Kucheeky Badkuya]

I actually liked Gundam Wing. G Gundam had its moments, but I really didn't like it.

Same here. I could stand Wing, btu G-Gundam just got my confued and pissed most of the time. Gundam X is better than both.

[Donkey Show]

G Gundam because you can't go wrong with the power of love. XD

[dspr8_rugged]

I'd rather watch Gundam X or any of the UC Gundam series... :P

IMO, Mobile Fighter G Gundam isn't to be taken seriously. It deviates from standard Gundam "warfare", so I can accept the ridiculous Gundam designs, cheesy lines, and a light story.

Gundam Wing, on the other hand, I also liked (actually, this is the first Gundam series that I've seen that made me hooked to other Gundam series...), in terms of mechanics and mecha battles. However, flawed characters, boring storyline and senseless and repeated talks about "peace", "pacifism", "war", etc. (read: Relena Peacecraft) shoot this series in the foot.

Given the two, I can stand G Gundam more than Gundam Wing.

[ssouske]

Since i like the more traditional gundam shows, i'll go for Gundam Wing... G Gundam is like a cross between gundam+dragon ball+super robots... which i find a bit interesting... but it did go against the gundam theme one way or the other... as an example, it is the only gundam show where the characters actually shout the names of their attacks... not doing so was one of the key features of gundam that made it different from the super robots of the 70's. why? because it was more realistic to not shout your attacks... can you immagine amuro shouting GUNDAM HAMMER!!! or BEAM RIFFLE!!! when he used those? :P
Wing on the other hand had most of the elements that made gundam shows great... it had pilots that did not shout "BUSTER RIFFLE!!!" it had politics, and etc... the but it also had its flaws... like emotionless characters... weak plot... an uber powerfull weapon slammed in a gundam... and a main pilot that can say only one phrase, which is "I WILL KILL YOU...":amuse other than those weak points, gundam wing is definitely better than G...
I liked seed better than those 2, but it also had its flaws... but over all i think SEED>WING>G...

[Naruto_San]

I LOVE G GUNDAM !The ending weirded me out a little.:blink

[Arsuran]

g-gundam really really sucked ( no offence) its like a big wrestling match with machines. In gundam wing in the other hand is like kill or be killed

[White Reflection]

W is consisted of 5 cockroaches who refuse to die and an aweful plot behind the flat storyline while having the most ugly female main character.
G is a Dragon ball Z version of gundam with some retarded grotesque mechas which deserves to be considered as pollution to the eye. Also the character's line is corny.

When it comes to the question which sucks less, I might have to vote for W since WZC is my second favorable MS next to Destiny.

[Wing-Zero]

gundam wing pwns g gundam

[Ha-ri]

W is consisted of 5 cockroaches who refuse to die and an aweful plot behind the flat storyline while having the most ugly female main character.
G is a Dragon ball Z version of gundam with some retarded grotesque mechas which deserves to be considered as pollution to the eye. Also the character's line is corny.

When it comes to the question which sucks less, I might have to vote for W since WZC is my second favorable MS next to Destiny.

How can you like Destiny with the plot-holes, no character def, shiin, and much mroe sucky-ness?

[White Reflection]

How can you like Destiny with the plot-holes, no character def, shiin, and much mroe sucky-ness?

Hmm Good point. Maybe I like Shinn because I am also anti-social? :blink Just kidding.
I do agree that the relationship between Glady and Dul is not well developped, and Neo deserved to get killed by Shinn in the end instead of becoming a Char clone inside that golden MS.
However the idea which they arrange the fight between two main characters (Shinn and Kira) is cool and kind unique.
The def for Shinn is a bit subtle but we can assume that deep inside of him, he wanted to protect Orb which explains in the end he burst joyful tears upon the message "Orb was saved". (Sigh: Again, dont let a kid do a man's job. Shinn is not badass enough to take down Kira.)
One more thing I would like to mention, Dul is not really evil. He did whatever it took for a politic to achieve his goal. His ideal is yet to be tested and we will never be able to justify destiny plan (Screw the hypocrite Lacus).
Now we all know there is gona be another sequal to Seed Destiny since the world is going back into a chaos again.

[kakashie-sensei]

g gundam rocked imo, but as far as i can say

Gundam Wing Pwns all

[Scorpio3.14]

G Gundam>>Gundam Wing

I personally liked the light heartedness of G Gundam. Its a change of pace from the regular gundam formula and it turned out pretty good in my opinion. It was not ment to be taken seriously, and if you dont it is a good show. Wing was good to, but I enjoyed G Gundam more.

[Pulp Fiction]

My Favorite anime is GunDam Wing

[Encronian]

personally i felt they were both horrible, i'd take X or Zeta over either of them, but since gundam wing have virtually no character development in the main characters aside from them getting more annoying. and since i like how the gundams were controlled in g gundam and i felt that it had a storyline that made my head hurt less then wings did, i'm gonna have to give G Gundam my vote in this one

[9Tail-Hokage]

I won't discrminate. Both!

[Megaharrison]

Gundam Wing for sure....G-Gundam was just a lame attempt to have the Gundam franchise appeal to the Shonen market.

That being said, G-Gundam wasn't TERRIBLE. It just can't stand up to the other series.

[Kunoichi no Kiri]

G-Gundam was just a lame attempt to have the Gundam franchise appeal to the Shonen market.

That being said, G-Gundam wasn't TERRIBLE. It just can't stand up to the other series.
I agree on both points.

But the fact is that Gundam Wing WAS terrible. At least G Gundam had a story and 3 dimensional characters.

G > Wing. Actually, I think G > All Gundams, but that's only because I don't care much for giant robots - a romance made G tolerable to me. I can see why most people would consider G one of the lesser Gundams, but Wing just SUCKED.

[Wildfire]

G Gundam because I watched every episode of it and I didn't really watch Gundam Wing that much when it was on. =/

[Donkey Show]

Two key points of why G Gundam is sooooooooooooooooooooo much better than the crap that is Gundam Wing.

#1 - Rain (yummy)
#2 - Bakunetsu God Finger Sekiha Love Love Tenkyoken (best move in anime, ever)

And the story was good too. XD But in all seriousness, it had the best drama and character interaction and development, unlike the cookie cutter G-Boys... ugh. It was a Gundam show and love story at the core, and it worked well. Definately my fave of all the Gundam series (and I'm a big UC fan).

If you intend to watch it seriously, you might want to watch the subbed version. I tried watching the dub, but it made my ears bleed. And c'mon, God Gundam >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Burning Gundam. ^^

[KinKaze]

No offense, but, G Gundam ISN'T really Gundam, like people said before, Gundam Wing looks more like original gundam series than G Gundam. I mean G gundam was really different. I don't like it.
I Know that many true Gundam Fans thinks that both Wing and G are one of the lesser Gundam Series. But still, Gundam Wing is FAR much better than G Gundam. And besides, let's admit it, Gundam Wing has really cool Gundams. (WingZeroCustom,HeavyArms,AltronCustom etc etc.)
As a protest, that Gundam Wing is much better than G Gundam, I put a Gundam Wing avatar/signature:amuse

[Kin]

Gundam Wing is far more better then the other Gundam series... It is a real dude anime which I like about animes that are ment for guys xDD

I mean! Gundam Seed, thats for guys and girls! :notrust so it makes it more girlish, which I dislike about an anime :noworry I say gundam Wing is the best! xDD

Btw...KinKaze...I like your siggie and avatar :hearts Trowa <3

[Mindless]

Gundam Wing is far more better then the other Gundam series... It is a real dude anime which I like about animes that are ment for guys xDD

I mean! Gundam Seed, thats for guys and girls! :notrust so it makes it more girlish, which I dislike about an anime :noworry I say gundam Wing is the best! xDD

Btw...KinKaze...I like your siggie and avatar :hearts Trowa <3

You mean that Gundam Wing is meant for girls, right? :huh

I mean, all of the guys are like super-good looking and have such good manners (when they feel like it). In my opinion, it's a Bishounen-Gundam. :oh

[KinKaze]

You mean that Gundam Wing is meant for girls, right? :huh

I mean, all of the guys are like super-good looking and have such good manners (when they feel like it). In my opinion, it's a Bishounen-Gundam. :oh

Yeah, I kinda agree, that the male characters are good looking for the girls. But so is Gundam Seed, Kira,Shinn, Athrun/Asuran (don't know whats the right spelling). They are kinda all Bishounen. But I guess if they wasn't, then only boys will watch Gundam series, So they got to do this, so that girls will watch it, I guess...(i'm not a girl so I don't know the reason...).

Anyway, they also say that Wing was kinda made for the Western market, to make Gundam more accessible.

(That's why it's also called "New Mobile Report Gundam Wing". Normally it would be Mobile Suit Gundam bla bla bla. So it's kinda different than what Gundam would be. But hey, It's still better than that (crap) G Gundam.:amuse

[Mindless]

G Gundam had it's moments. I, for one, loved when Master Asia and Domon fought (in episode 44 or something). I thought that was really cool. :)

[Shadowscar]

Although G Gundam was good Gundam Wing rules.

[Lord Of Reapers]

I actually liked Wing. I havent seen every episode but id rather watch it than G Gundam. I found G Gundam uninteresting.

[pi321]

G Gundamn was sooo lame with the jump suits and crap and the plot sucked but I watched it to see rain :P...Gundam Wing was waaaaay better and is still one of my fav'...btw endless waltz ROCKED

[Supa Swag]

I personally think G Gundam is one of the worst pieces of shit I have ever set my eyes upon. And the ending...OH GOD THE ENDING!

Wing in a landslide.

[S.o.L]

I took the time to download both of the subbed versions. And Gundam Wing came out on top. G Gundam was just weird, and the plot wasn't that great. While I will admit Gundam Wing has an advantege because it was my first Gundam series, it actaully had a decent plot, with interesting and diverse characters. Plus the Mobile Suit designs outclass those of G Gundam.

[Scared Link]

Gundam Wing! That's an instant classic. When I saw Hero getting shot by Duo to Zechs dying! It's one of the best anime ever!

[Crys]

G Gundam was funner than Gundam Wing, but Gundam Wing brought you know....war and stuff. it's impossible to choose really, they're too different...

[Son Goku]

gundam wing and after endless waltz gundam lost its best seires

[Razgriez]

G Gundam had far too many sterotypes. I liked Gundam Wing much better.

[Chamcham Trigger]

Gundam wing is my favorite. I'm not a big mech anime fan, but I loved this one. It was the only one I could really sit through all the way excited about the next episodes.

[KuwabaraTheMan]

G Gundam, by far. Its a pretty good series, with a great cast, and some good comedy and serious stuff(consecutive deaths of Schwartz and Master Asia). It was over the top, but that was part of what made it great.

Gundam Wing is the worst 'real Gundam' series(SD is worse, but...), and an embarassment to the franchise. It was the first Gundam I ever saw, and thankfully Toonami quickly aired Mobile Suit Gundam, because otherwise I may have never become a Gundam fan.

Wing was rediculous with a lame cast of unbeatable pretty boys, almost no likable characters aside from Treize(Wufei was alright for a little while, as was Lady Une, but they both grew stale later on, too), and retarded fake 'philosophy'. Killing in the name of pacifism, what the hell is that?

The final episode is a trainwreck of epic proportion.

Only slight dramatization:
*Heero and Zechs fighting a pointless battle*
Heero: I want pacifism.
Zechs: I want to achieve pacifism, by killing you, and millions of people so that the world learns pacifism.
World: Hey, we're ready for pacifism now.
Zechs: Quiet, you!

Not to mention that fight was like Nu Gundam vs. Sazabi from Char's Counterattack, without all the good parts, and there being no reason for them to actually fight.

How anyone can enjoy Wing with all that crap going on is beyond me...

[Shadow Raki]

G Gundam because I never saw Gundam Wing.

[crazymtf]

G Gundam, by far. Its a pretty good series, with a great cast, and some good comedy and serious stuff(consecutive deaths of Schwartz and Master Asia). It was over the top, but that was part of what made it great.

Gundam Wing is the worst 'real Gundam' series(SD is worse, but...), and an embarassment to the franchise. It was the first Gundam I ever saw, and thankfully Toonami quickly aired Mobile Suit Gundam, because otherwise I may have never become a Gundam fan.

Wing was rediculous with a lame cast of unbeatable pretty boys, almost no likable characters aside from Treize(Wufei was alright for a little while, as was Lady Une, but they both grew stale later on, too), and retarded fake 'philosophy'. Killing in the name of pacifism, what the hell is that?

The final episode is a trainwreck of epic proportion.

Only slight dramatization:
*Heero and Zechs fighting a pointless battle*
Heero: I want pacifism.
Zechs: I want to achieve pacifism, by killing you, and millions of people so that the world learns pacifism.
World: Hey, we're ready for pacifism now.
Zechs: Quiet, you!

Not to mention that fight was like Nu Gundam vs. Sazabi from Char's Counterattack, without all the good parts, and there being no reason for them to actually fight.

How anyone can enjoy Wing with all that crap going on is beyond me...

Bingo! :P Just what my opinion is. Though G-gundam isn't the greatest it's far better then Wing in every section except maybe MAYBE animation but everything else far better, ESPECIALLY THE ENDING. Well all in all TO ME G-Gundam hands down owned Wing.

[Kunoichi no Kiri]

I love you G Gundam fans T___T <3

G Gundam was the only Gundam series I liked. At all.

The rest was just mobile suit penissery with guns and explosions and retarded plots.

[crazymtf]

I love you G Gundam fans T___T <3

G Gundam was the only Gundam series I liked. At all.

The rest was just mobile suit penissery with guns and explosions and retarded plots.

Yes...You are right :wtf

[Diz]

I prefer G Gundam I dont like the other gundams cause they were boring to me to much talking lol,i like the fights in g gundam there really intense and leave you hanging.it also like martial art gundams which is pretty cool.

[Raistlin-sama]

The rest was just mobile suit penissery with guns and explosions and retarded plots.
All of them? I'd have to disagree a whole lot.

If Zeta Gundam is "mobile suit penissery with guns and explosions and retarded plots.", then my idea of good plot and characters must be rather of, considering what a great series I think it is in those regards.

[Yuugi's Black Magician]

G Gundam is by far, MUCH better then Gundam Wing. Let's break it down:

G Gundam was essentially what Tomino's Gundam was about, relationships and God knows G Gundam really banged that through. The plot was simple, sure, but it was dramatic and well directed and written, without the extrodinary writing team and the great direction, G Gundam would have been lost. Wing on the other hand, never seemed to really go anywhere, the G-Boys got annoying, the Gundam's were so overpowered Wing made the MSG (1979) look more realistic then the 1995 NMRGW.

That and Wing had clips shows, for the love of God, clips shows!! What's with that.

MAHQ (mahq.com) has detailed reviews on both series, compare and you'll see what makes G Gundam so much better (at least in my opinion).

[Donkey Show]

SEKIHA LOVE LOVE TENKYOKEN!!!

[Mugendai-Shi]

i liked both but I prefer Gundam Wing because of it's story

[whitehawk]

I say Gundam Wing i think its better than the rest of them
but thats just me
i seen all the eps. and the movies
of Gundam Wing
plus i didnt like the series right after Gundam Wing because,
well, i dont know i just didnt like the series after GW

[C.]

I liked both of them....but then again I was a kid when i saw both of them so i really didn't get all the lame charcters, stupid conversation, steryotypes and all that other chracter stuff...I just liked when things go boom.

personally while most of the gundam models in G gundam sucked, Shadow gundam is one of my favorite gundams of all time...

[gregjalepeno]

Gundam Wing. 'Nuff said.

[Violent By Design]

I liked both of them....but then again I was a kid when i saw both of them so i really didn't get all the lame charcters, stupid conversation, steryotypes and all that other chracter stuff...I just liked when things go boom.

personally while most of the gundam models in G gundam sucked, Shadow gundam is one of my favorite gundams of all time...
Yup lol. Exaclty what he said.

[Supa Swag]

My opinion has not changed. I don't care if G Gundam is supposed to be a joke it is one of the most terrible pieces of monkey shit I have ever seen. If it ended at the first episode it would have been decent. Instead they had to devolve it into a gigantic piece of shit.

[Suzumebachi]

G Gundam easily. Windmill Gundam FTW! But really, Nazi ninja and russian dominatrix? How can you go wrong?

[GoldenJoe]

definatly gundam wing!

[BlaZeR]

Gundam Wing but I was a kid when i watched it and Epyon pwned all.

[S.o.L]

Neither, Gundam X WTF PWNS the shit out of both of em, but if I were to say which is better I would say Gundam Wing. Just because G Gundam was like a bad episode of Power Rangers. Also the Gundam designs were horrible.

[cyphon14]

Gundam wing for sure. The Deathscythe and Heavyarms pwned!

[exmorte]

G Gundam for the hilarious factor. Sure both of them made me laugh at the stupidity. But G was supposed to make you laugh.

[NU-KazeKage]

Gundam Wing but I was a kid when i watched it and Epyon pwned all.
he still does my friend he still does

[$!@de]

oh gundam wing totaly.

[Iruka]

Gundam Wings will always remain my favorite Gundam series.

[Donkey Show]

Master Asia would pwn all the Gundams in Gundam Wing by himself.

[Mindless]

The Master Gundam is kinda powerful after all. :P

[Donkey Show]

The Master Gundam is kinda powerful after all. :P
I was talking about the person himself. XD

[Mindless]

I was talking about the person himself. XD

Haha, yeah, he's interesting. :amuse

[Suzie]

Gundam Wing is gonna be my fav gundam series forever ^___^

[LayZ]

No question, Gundam Wing.

[Comic Book Guy]

I prefer Gundam Wing over G Gundam.

But in a match up?

G Gundam horribly destroys Gundam Wing.

[trowas_little_angel]

I really love Gundam Wing. I've watched mech animes since i was a little kid. I had two episodes of Robotech on VHS, and i would watch that none stop, i must have been about 7 - 8 (I'm almost 18 now).
People say there are lots of flaws in GWing, but i usually fail to see how them people are right. Most of the time they are wrong. I've not seen G-Gundam so i can't choose between the both, but i'm atleast going to give Gundm wing a few points.

Spoilers for ALL of Gundam Wing Anime/Manga

The Gundam Wing Boys are emotionless. That has to be the most common, and that's all Heero's fault. Heero shows so little emotion that it's not noticeable, unless you look hard and you understand his feelings. No matter how many times he tells Relena, Zechs, or Trieze "I'll kill you." he doesn't. Relena still lives, Zechs kinda sacrificed himself, and Wufei was the one to kill Treize. Heero was trained not to show emotion, but it's there. When he killed that little girl by accident, he didn't show any emotion, but he still picked up the little dog and flower the girl had given him. No one knows where, but he never forgot. He never forgot the day her killed her in the accident. Becuase of Heero people fail to see the emotion in the other characters. I mean saying that Quatre, Wufei and Duo have no emotion is biggest load of rubbish i can ever hear about them. When Quatre's father is killed he cries, when he shoots Trowa and he goes missing, Quatre never stops blaming himself. When Wufei's colony was destoried and when he finally kills Treize, he burst into tears... I think that's an emotion... yeah it's called Sadness, depression, what ever you want to call it, but it is emotion. Duo... well he's just duo lol. Okay now Trowa... It's true Trowa doesn't have emotion, but can you blame him? He lost his family, he doesn't know his name,

It has a weak plot line. Huh, yeah right. People who don't undestand politics may say that alot, but in truth it's plot line is one of the most advanced things i've watched in years. And it's all political, which is what you'd expect in a war. Yeah, It's a war! Wars are usually started and ended by politics, with a whole lot of politics in the middle. The constant shift of the organisations in power is normal. and having Gundams as a rebal alliance is normal too.

The Gundam Wing boys have very little past Well obvioulsy these people haven't read the Episode 0 manga.... Point closed

Other points
First thing i want to say is it's not chessy. If you really want cheesy, watch the english version of Sailor Moon, believe me, i own the english sailor moon and i know the definition of 'cheesy'. (the Japanese is better :P)

Next thing is the gundams are rare models, there's only five of them to begin with. Then there's the repacements and updates. Now as i've said i haven't watched G-Gundam, but it seems that there are lots of them, at least 40. doesn't seem right to me. As I said they arte rare MS and hard to make. and if that isn't the case in G-Gundam, then why?

I started reading up on G-Gundam when i got into GWing and I couldn't help but gag at the 'Mobile Trace System'. Give me Manual Controls anyday. They make a lot more sense (except in Endless Waltz, when Trowa does his circus'y flip in his Gundam. Either he's VERY talented or it makes no sense.) There were other things that made me laugh or gag. Hyper-mode, and Super-mode; Remided me of Digimon, DBZ or Sailor Moon. It was very amusing to read up.

[Rukia]

I would pick anything over G Gundam. G Gundam just didn't feel like a gundam series to me. (Plus I despise Domon.)

[2Shea]

My god yes, Wing over G Gundam any day. I absolutely dispise anything to do with G Gundam.

[Donkey Show]

I would pick anything over G Gundam. G Gundam just didn't feel like a gundam series to me. (Plus I despise Domon.)
Well... that was the whole point of creating the Alternate Universes anyway, to break the mold from what Gundam followed. It's just a quasi super robot series with Gundams as the fighters. It never tried to be anything UC like, unlike Wing which it's story pales in comparison.

[Kuwabara99]

I like both series. But G Gundam is my fav series of all the Gundam series.
The story, the characters, the way things turned out. A win-win.

Gundam Wing turned me off a lot with the constant angsty characters and too much random killing

[Shunsuii]

G Gundam, I love the story, the character and the twists. Gundam Wing was nice but, I kinda forced myself to watch the last 10 episodes, it started getting boring. G Gundam was a really good series. Ofcourse Gundam Wing's Gundam are drawn better since they have improved over a couple of years, so its common sense for the suits to be better drawn. Other than that.....

G Gundam FTW

[momolade]

I watched the gundam wing DUB
and liked it >.>

[Jams]

I won't discrminate. Both!

Same! Both are good series, and although I think G Gundam's better as a series, Wing was my first Gundam, and its still a pretty good series.

[Seto Kaiba]

I like both, but I prefer Gundam Wing. G Gundam seemed kinda excessively flashy at times IMO.

[GoldenJoe]

gundam wing. in my opinion g gundam sucks hard

[Fai]

Gundam Wing :nod

[suiken_kempou]

Gundam Wing especially Waltz was drawn many times better than G Gundam. I also think that G Gundam had a very DBZ esque power explosion that kind of seamed a little strange to me. Besides the Wing pilots were much more B.A than the G Gundam pilots by far.

[Vic Vinegar]

gundam wing
the only one i ever saw!

[Chatulio]

Do not comapre any other series to g gundam since all the other are superior to that one >.<

[Raven Eyes]

G gundam all the way...

two words...

shining fingers

[Biscuits]

I enjoyed G Gundam more because of the plot and characters/Gundams,except the part where the pilots have powers outside the Gundams WTF!
Master Asia was taking out Moblie suits with his scarf..just hilarous.

[staradderdragoon]

ive never seen g gundam but i'll say gundam wing has much better art!

[teh Panda]

wing has to be one of my all time favs...some say its bad and characters are shallow...but i really liked the politics...and treize's plan to bring an end to all wars like a play was great.

g gundam i liked too, but i love all gundam series...except turn A ...:notrust
the god finger translation was whack in america, but the fights were tight in a DBZ kind of way.

...and Rain Mikamura is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO hot.

Wing>G

[Taleran]

wow this Board seriously lacks in its Hot-blooded awesome quotient


I like both equally and it depends what mood I'm in.

[Kay-kun]

I would definately go with G-gundam. I watched the series too many times to count. Gundam Wing was the first Gundam series I saw....it's okay but G-gundam kept me interested the whole way thru

[Halcyon Days]

I liked the gundams better in Wing, and it seemed to have more drama and an all-around sense of endless danger for the pilots

[Zephos]

Both are equally goofy.
But G just knows it, while Wing seems to think its a serious war drama and not a melodramatic invincible pretty boy poster with vague attempts at war philosophy.

Go G.

[Halcyon Days]

Wing...go zero

[C.]

Some parts of G Gundam were interesting....but it really felt more like DBZ with robots then a Gundam series. I would say Gundam wing, the action was nice even if the plot was sub par.

[fennixfire]

I fell in love with G Gundam! Go G!

[mary no jutsu]

I wasn't really that crazy about either of them. But i'd say i'd go for wing, as annoying as they were I don't think I could really watch those gundams fight without laughing.

[Grandmaster Kane]

I dont know they both pwn so much

but if i had to pick id go with wing

altron gundam is teh shit

[Impulse17]

GUNDAM WING RUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUULES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!

[Jetstorm]

Don't make me choose!:cry

Damn, I have to go with Gundam Wing.

[Pasty]

I had to struggle through every episode of G Gundam, I prefer wing by a long shot.

[Suzaku of Hidden Flame]

Though I enjoyed Wing, I like G Gundam better.

Also, does anybody know the title to the song (in G Gundam) when God Gundam uses the God Finger?

[Suzumebachi]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ku0e6fb2x8

[BlackShinobi]

I prefer gundam G

[Adjective-Noun]

BAKUNETSU GOD FINGER SEIKIHA LOVE LOVE TENKYOKEN!!!

G Gundam was kung-fu giant robots complete with it's own ancient master and a romance that made sense. If you don't like it, then you aren't a real man.

[General Mustang]

I liked G Gundam the best, it was perfect

[Cyckness]

I had to struggle through every episode of G Gundam, I prefer wing by a long shot.

My opinion has not changed. I don't care if G Gundam is supposed to be a joke it is one of the most terrible pieces of monkey shit I have ever seen. If it ended at the first episode it would have been decent. Instead they had to devolve it into a gigantic piece of shit.


agreed....

[Lord Yu]

G Gundam, Gundam Wing was filled with copy pasta and self contradictory philosophy. G Gundam was filled with fun and Hot blood.

[Cobra]

Gundam Wing is better than G Gundam because it doesnt involve gundams battleing hand to hand as its main theme

[Beauty Blade Alchemist]

Go G Gundam! I loved that show! It's the only mecha anime that I really truly like.

[Crimson Dragoon]

You have got to be kidding me. G-Gundam stomps this. It's a far better show since it doesn't take itself too seriously and has no angsty bishies.

[Adachi]

I watched G Gundam, but never Gundam Winng. However, ironically I seem to like Wing better than G Gundam...:zaru

[kulgan18]

Dude what the hell, they are almost completly different genre.
G gundam tries more to be like the super robot shows, Gundam wing is closest to the other gundams...

So if you like other gundams go with gundam wing.

[Halcyon Days]

Indeed, I say Gundam wing trumps it.

[Dimezanime20]

Are you serious? G-Gundam, end of story!

[Halcyon Days]

O please Wign Zero rules. The only thing I liked that was different in G was the actual controlling of the Gundam. Besides that I liked the battles better in Wing and the somplex plot , but I did like Domon's intensity but he seemed to get angry at anyone way to easy. the gundams seemed better in Wing also....Just my opinion

[colours]

Gundam Wing :sag

[Inuhanyou]

its too close, g gundam i liked cause of its uniqe take on the series as a whole and the presentation wasnt bad either.

But i also like W gundam simply because of the nostolgia i get, it was my very first gundam series after all. But the end reminded me of a few other gundams before that i could mention, so it doesnt score in originality.

Over all i'll have to put W gundam ahead of G gundam, simply because it pulls off the main dudes killing fodder enemies easier, with that "zero system" implanted. Works better to me then somehow having a super saiyan mode without explanation (lol@g gundam gold)

[Rated R Superstar]

G Gundam was better in my opinion. I liked the fact that it was different than the rest.

[Bullitt]

No comparision Gundam Wing is way better, G Gundam was just ugh it would take to long to explain why it sucks compared to the other series. Id still rather watch G gundam over most anything not Gundam though =P

[kunaitoe]

Oooh thats such an evil choice to ask us to make, but I supposed I would have to say Gundam Wing because there were more characters that I liked.

[Halcyon Days]

Dimezanime and Rated R Superstar, your sigs are great. *2 Thumbs way up*

[united]

i haven't seen everything of G yet but i must say that Gundam wing is much better at this point

[Stallyns808]

I prefer G Gundam. It's much more entertaining and it has some great emotional moments. I love Gundam Wing as well, but I like it more for the Gundams themselves than the actual story or characters.

[crabman]

G Gundam wins hands down. Like yeah, it was silly and yeah Holland will never make a wind mill gundam, and Mexico doesn't have an immigration problem, and Master Asia is the most kick ass hero ever, like his level of awesomeness is practically on par with that of Char Aznable, and he's like what the 2nd most Garest anime character in the entire anime universe, and for once they decided a war isn't the best way to have an anime.

Yeah, Gundam Wing didn't have nearly as many memorable moments or characters. But I still liked Gundam Wing.

[HEATAQUA]

G Gundam because it's awesome

[crabman]

Why isn't this a poll thread? I want to see how many of my brethren are out there.

[Stallyns808]

G Gundam wins hands down. Like yeah, it was silly and yeah Holland will never make a wind mill gundam, and Mexico doesn't have an immigration problem, and Master Asia is the most kick ass hero ever, like his level of awesomeness is practically on par with that of Char Aznable, and he's like what the 2nd most Garest anime character in the entire anime universe, and for once they decided a war isn't the best way to have an anime.

Master Asia was :awesome. I teared up when he died, same for when Domon had to kill Kyoji/Schwarz. My fave G Gundam episodes go to the ones where they died.

[O]

G-Gundam. Nothing makes better combat robots than FUCKING RACIAL STEREOTYPES!

http://img291.imageshack.us/img291/5005/tequilaky0.jpg

Oh, I'm sure the nacho eaters are proud of their fighting machine that's named after an alcoholic beverage! Fuck, it even has a mustache and cactus arms!

Speaking of which, did anyone notice Neo-Japan was the only nation that had a slick looking non-stereotype Gundam? Domon should have piloted the fucking Sushi Gundam.

[Halcyon Days]

master asia's master gundam wasn't stereotyped, but his tokyo gundam was.

[O]

master asia's master gundam wasn't stereotyped, but his tokyo gundam was.

Master Asia was fucking badass. No one would dare to give him non-badass mecha.

[Halcyon Days]

Who do you guys think would win in a match? The 5 from gundam wing or the 5 from G Gundam in a team vs. team [no gold mode]

[Stallyns808]

Who do you guys think would win in a match? The 5 from gundam wing or the 5 from G Gundam in a team vs. team [no gold mode]

Heero takes it alone. :LOS

Seriously, I gotta say it's a tough pick. Either Wing Zero or God/Burning Gundam could solo either side. It all depends on which is greater, Zero or God/Burning? I'd probably have to go with Zero since it's buster cannon has a wide area of damage and God/Burning Gundam would get caught in it.

[piratej62]

SHINNING FINGER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'll go with G-gundam

[O]

THE EAST IS BURNING BREAD!

[Altron]

Gundam Wing was the one that got me into mecha and the gundam series and still the best in my opinion. :awesome

[crabman]

THE EAST IS BURNING BREAD!

IT'S LOUD ROAR TELLS ME TO GRASP PASTRIES!

[Dimezanime20]

C/S thread.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cwyVV5_orBo

[Halcyon Days]

seriously, I wouldn't think that either heero or Domon would be able to solo either side. It would seem that zero and Burning gundam would probably cancel eachother out in a clash between the buster rifle and the burning finger. I'd say it would be left up to the rest of teh team.

[Isegar_Kashim]

Gundam Wing for me. G, in my opinion, is more of a guilty pleasure. Wing got me to the Gundam craze and anime.

[dspr8_rugged]

A lot got into Gundam because of Wing.

[Stallyns808]

^That's true. I even bought a couple of the model kits because of Wing. Mostly the Endless Waltz versions of the Gundams. I bought the DVDs for both Wing & G. But watching them, I kinda find Wing boring now but G Gundam I can keep on watching the show over and over again. It's the reason why I prefer G more. I can still watch it and not get bored, but Wing got stale for me after awhile.

[KuwabaraTheMan]

seriously, I wouldn't think that either heero or Domon would be able to solo either side. It would seem that zero and Burning gundam would probably cancel eachother out in a clash between the buster rifle and the burning finger. I'd say it would be left up to the rest of teh team.

Sekiha Love Love Tenkyoken could take it alone.

Angsty pretty boys without personality can't stand up to the power of love.

Besides all they need is for Heero to promise to kill them and they're guaranteed to survive.

[~Shin~]

Master Asia.

'nuff said.

[Jackal]

Gundam Wing had a pretty good plot. and the fact that they actually had to "pilot" the gundams in gundam wing made it better. instead of wearing tights and dancing. :arg

[KuwabaraTheMan]

Gundam Wing had a pretty good plot. and the fact that they actually had to "pilot" the gundams in gundam wing made it better. instead of wearing tights and dancing. :arg

Gundam Wing's 'plot' was just a nonsensical, jumbled together remix of the plots of Mobile Suit Gundam, Zeta Gundam and Char's Counterattack, but with all the character moments taken out and a bunch of nonsense added in every so often to make it seem deep.

[jazz189]

Two words
Shining Finger

[Stallyns808]

Master Asia.

'nuff said.

:lmao All that needs to be said about G Gundam. Master Asia FTW!

[milhaus007]

Imma have to say Gundam Wing is a slight bit better than G Gundam.

Domon Kasshu > Master Asia :wink

SHINING FINGER FTW !

[O]

G Gundam, for the racism.

[Toffeeman]

Wing is one of the better Gundam series' PERIOD imo.

[milhaus007]

Two words
Shining Finger

http://i253.photobucket.com/albums/hh79/milhaus007/Shining_Finger___Ala_Bush__by_Nydyn.jpg


:nuts:nuts:nuts

[Minzara]

I hate G Gundam with all my heart, Its not only the most hated Gundam for me, its my most hated anime ever. Its only surpassed by my hatred for Napoleon Dynamite. So, to answer the question. I prefer Gundam Wing. :zaru

[milhaus007]

I hate G Gundam with all my heart, Its not only the most hated Gundam for me, its my most hated anime ever. Its only surpassed by my hatred for Napoleon Dynamite. So, to answer the question. I prefer Gundam Wing. :zaru


Both G Gundam and Gundam Wing were awesome. But I do agree with you on Napoleon Dynamite. That movie was so dumb. I want back 2 hours of my life.

[saphyre_bloo]

G Gundam for me . i love domon and rain :wtf

[Halcyon Days]

G Gundam for me . i love domon and rain :wtf

I was surprised she went back with him. She should've left him long ago

[Cloud]

Gundam 00 or Destiny.


If I have to choose, it would be wing. I hate G gundam with a passion.

[Big Boss]

G GUNDAM!!!!!!

[united]

haven't watched g through the end yet but so far i'm still going for gundam wing

[NewtypeS3]

...jeeze lahweeze, so many people here not getting the point of either G-Gundam or Gundam Wing.

Back in the start of 1994, Gundam was in a bit of a slump. Yoshiyuki Tomino, the man who had made Gundam what it is from day one, had just called it quits - trying to sink his own franchise with the 1993 work Victory Gundam. While sales for the OVAs being released at the time (0080 and 0083) were solid and well, the ratings for Victory Gundam were literally in the toilet - far worse than the ratings for Mobile Suit Gundam's first series... which was cancelled due to low ratings!
So Sunrise wanted to do something new. But what? Tomino was gone, he didn't want to do any more. The Universal Century was apparently being tapped dry (ironic, considering Japan now can't get enough of it, it seems), so what could they do? And all of this was going on with 1994 also being Gundam's 15th Anniversary!

So Sunrise brought in a new director and told him to do as he wished. This guy decided to actually pay tribute to all those Super Robot shows Gundam had made a concentrated effort to 'escape' back in 1979 - Daitarn-3, Zambot-3, the Getter Robo franchise and the Mazinger family of shows, among others (perhaps ironically, Tomino's works before Gundam were mostly super robot shows, such as Daitarn and Zambot). However, he also wanted to keep Gundam's message about war being bad and the other themes of the Gundam franchise intact. So the new development team combined them together - and it certainly didn't help that a certain fighting anime that had been based around finding seven orange orbs to grant a wish was in it's prime popularity either.
Thus, G-Gundam was born.

The series was a drastic change from what came before. The announcer actually looked to the audience to tell them what was going on in this Future Century, where colonies were literally vast chunks of Earth's Real-Estate that had been ripped from the ground itself and carted into space. And if that weren't enough, there wasn't even a Gundam to be stolen/found in the first episode (a proud tradition that, quite frankly, only 0080 had actually broken beforehand - but never a series...!)! Domon Kashuu started out with the Gundam - and he proved himself to be not only a capable pilot, but a martial artist of insane skill within the first episode alone! That's right, the fans were in for something different. Yet... it was familiar all the same.
And that's why I love G-Gundam. The show bucked the trends worn thin by UC, yet kept the main themes of Gundam all the same. Despite going back to Gundam's Super Robot heritage (some might even argue Tokusatsu heritage as well - the Kamen Riders and Power Rangers/Sentai shows of olden days), the show retained the main themes of 'war sucks' and 'humanity may try for peace, but we often fail - only to try again.' But the way they were presented were different. And we even gained new themes - those of 'friendship' (something that had never really been touched upon at all) and 'united, we can do anything.' That last one was a little interesting, considering that the former theme is needed to use the latter - and Gundam had barely focused on the idea of friendship outside 'we work together on the same side.'
G-Gundam, meanwhile, promoted the idea of 'no matter our nationality, we can and will work together.' Despite the stereotypes lopped on top of each Gundam from each country, G-Gundam could actually be considered one of the more progressive anime out there - no one country is considered inferior to another. Compare this to Destiny, where Orb is literally a Japan that can do no wrong, and you've got a drastic difference.

Of course, G-Gundam has flaws of it's own. It's a little too fantastical for Gundam - the technology and the moves Domon continually pulls out of his nether regions are comparable to most Super Robot anime - especially the more recent Tengen Toppa Gurren-Lagann. The voice acting on both sides of the shore is lacking - but in a cheesy way that hearkens back to the Super Robot days of yore in the 1970's before Gundam was around.
On top of this, G-Gundam might be a little too positive. Despite the sheer love of the Earth that all the Gundam Fighters had in the end, it turned out that none of the countries really trusted one another. After all, Neo-Holland had 40 different Hurricane Gundams hidden in their colony - and Neo-Egypt had the Sphinx Gundam. Neo-America had their Statue of Liberty Cannon (and a Neo-MacArthur, to boot), and Neo-Denmark had thousands of Mermaid Gundam prototypes hidden within a massive mothership. And yet, after all this betrayal and breaking of treaties, the ending is still positive that the Gundam Fight will work - despite the inherent flaws within.

After G-Gundam, Bandai realized that creating an alternate universe was a great thing. So, of course, they made another - one much closer to the UC than G-Gundam was. With a new era in warfare fast approaching, one vastly different from the WWII upon which the Universal Century was based upon, Gundam Wing was born.

Oddly enough, one could consider Wing ahead of it's time in terms of themes. Only now are we starting to replace warriors on the battlefield with machines, 12 years after Wing thought it was probable. However, it's not with Mobile Dolls, but with scouting drones and roaming gun turrets. The theme of 'humans vs machines' was something brand-new to the Gundam franchise; something so drastic, it hasn't been used since.
On top of that, Wing was the first series to look upon the 'why' of war - not just the events of the war, but the effects it had on the people as well as how the war happened in the first place (all of the other shows just had the war 'in progress' as we joined our characters - extremely so in CCA). Certainly, First Gundam took efforts to show how the Side-7 refugees were displaced, as well as how Amuro's mother coped... but that was it. 0080 also touched upon the idea, but barely went beyond Al's limited point of view. Wing, however, literally took a roaming trip all around the Earth Sphere and beyond in finding out what many people thought of the events whirling around them. We saw Relena's PoV, we saw the PoV of the little child and her Grandfather, we saw the PoV of the victim of War's cruelty (Sylvia Noventa... but don't worry if you don't remember her). The audience was treated with so many different points of view, the Gundam Pilots were often lost in the shuffle of the plot itself, with characters like Wufei shoved aside for a good dozen episodes or more.
Like G before it, Wing also kept the previous messages of 'friendship' and 'together, we can beat anything,' but lessened the impact of them to an extent. While the pilots would still make connections on a personal level, there would be no magical pulling-attacks-from-the-nether-regions in order to save the day like in G (unless you read the Wing series' manga ending, unofficial as it was). Wing also kept the messages of 'war sucks' and 'humanity repeats it's mistakes' as well - with much of an emphasis on the former. Entirely new to Gundam, though, was the idea of pacifism. The UC OVAs had toyed with the idea of neutrality (as did first, with Side-6), but Wing was the first to try and deliver the overly-idealistic message of total pacifism. Not that everyone in the show agreed with it, but hey.
Also, as with G-Gundam, Wing continued to buck the trend of (insert main character) finds/steals Gundam. This time around, all 5 of the Gundams (another aspect borrowed from G, as well as the director's previous work of Shogun Warriors) were owned by teens from the start... all of whom had some major training with the unit before the start of the series.
It should also be noted that, compared to the WWII of UC, Wing was a lot closer to Vietnam in tone. No one really wanted the war, but they were in the middle of it, so they might as well try to finish the war off (and please, refrain from Iraq comments).

[To be concluded, due to text limits.]

[NewtypeS3]

[Concluded, due to text limitations.]

However, Wing suffered from some serious flaws as well. Much like a diamond ring with a crack in it, had the flaws been fixed the entire package would be beautiful. As it is, Wing is just left at 'so close, so far.'
The biggest flaw is the lack of backstory in the animation. The best we got was the narrator giving us a vague summary of the events of the last 15 years - and even then, it wasn't enough to be fully prepared without extensive minor flashbacking by a few characters. And, had internal politics not gotten in the way, we would have gotten the backstory needed.
The manga Episode Zero was set to become the events taking place in episodes 27 and 28, further fleshing out the After Colony era and giving many characters a much-needed depth and background. Characters like Heero might not have needed the depth, but other characters like Wufei and Duo actually suffered quite a lot from the lack. Wufei's actions, without the depiction of his wife's demise, comes off as completely chauvinistic and woman-hating - while all he was trying to do was make sure another woman didn't die in vain while he was around (unfortunately, much of the fanbase has latched onto the stereotype, blowing it even further out of proportion). With Duo, it's rather similar. Without the pain and loss in his life shown in the animation, so-called fans have presumed Duo to be completely sane and always happy... when it's almost completely obvious that the happiness and sanity is just a mask covering the shattered remains of his childhood (Parents? Dead. The orphan, Solo, he took his name from? Dead. Orphan group he was with? Scattered or dead. The church that took him in? Slaughtered. Not a good basis for sanity).
Admittedly, we do still have Episode Zero's manga form. And it was taken from the actual scripts intended for the episodes themselves - however, Wing itself seriously lacks the punch needed by including Episode Zero (it should be noted that Gundam 00 also seems to have the idea of an 'Episode Zero' by including child Setsuna in episode 1).
Another problem with Wing was the fact that the plot could get somewhat convoluted at times. Many of my friends who enjoyed the show would get confused over the randomly-popping-up factions like the White Fang and the Treize Faction. Well, to be specific, the White Fang. Literally, they did come out of nowhere - a nowhere that would have been somewhere had Episode Zero been put into episode format.
The only other major problem was a lack of romance. Really, while this is technically unimportant, it sticks out to come after G - which had a really large romance between Domon and Rain. This really gave certain fans a base with which to launch baseless yaoi and random pairings based on no more than a few minutes' footage (Trowa x Relena? Relena x Wufei? When did THEY meet?). However, this is somewhat understandable when one factors in the fact that the Director admits to believing he couldn't write a good romance - not to mention that the main 5 pilots were only 15. And, hey, the two pairings we did get officially (Treize x Une and Noin x Zechs) were surprisingly well-done, so it almost cancels it all out.
However, despite these flaws, I still enjoy watching Wing - perhaps because of the Heavyarms Disco stock footage, or maybe because it's a unique plot on it's own. Or maybe because its my first Gundam show.

As for which I like more... I won't decide. They're both excellent shows - and both are well within my 'top ten' for Gundam.

[Halcyon Days]

Could you please shorten this

[crabman]

Shortened I think it basically states:

As for which I like more... I won't decide. They're both excellent shows - and both are well within my 'top ten' for Gundam.

[Inuhanyou]

Cant i choose both?? Heero was the coolest but at the same time i also liked domon :arg

[crabman]

The winds of the king!

[TheWon]

Some one made a thread for this. Wing hands down! Why? 2 words
Mummy Gundam!
G is a JOKE!

[Red Zaku]

Some one made a thread for this. Wing hands down! Why? 2 words
Mummy Gundam!
G is a JOKE!


Someone got his Gundam series backwards. >.> oops. Mummy or Neo Egypts Pharaoh Gundam is from G-Gundam not Wing. By the way. Both are great shows end of topic.

[Biolink]

Lol.

He was saying that Wing wins hands down, because of G Gundam's "Mummy Gundam", not because "Mummy Gundam" was in Wing Gundam.

He just worded it, kinda funny I guess.

[Red Zaku]

Lol.

He was saying that Wing wins hands down, because of G Gundam's "Mummy Gundam", not because "Mummy Gundam" was in Wing Gundam.

He just worded it, kinda funny I guess.

>.> Kinda funny? No he worded it almost as badly as Bush Jr's famous OBGYN speech.

[Biolink]

"Too many OBGYN'S Can't *Thinks for a second* Practice their love with women"

Yes Dubya is great for the lulz.

[Halcyon Days]

Domon was justa little too overdramatic to me. I mean how many times do u have to learn the same lesson before it hits. He's as much of a block head as Yususke.

but both were great series.

[Michael Myers]

g gundam was more gritty and violent for me. It was darker and domon was a beast. the fights were epic as hell.

[Totitos]

xHSSDFBQ2Co

[Biolink]

Nice Ryoma Ava and sig. Hell you even have Dio thrown into the Spoilers to top it off. Even more win.

[Darth Caedus]

I consider Wing to be the second worst Gundam. Only SD is worse imo.

The originals are the best anyway. G takes this easily.

[NewtypeS3]

I'd love to hear your reasoning for that, Mr. Irvine. After all, you claim the 'orignials' are better, yet insult SD Gundam - a franchise built upon spoofing the original Gundam series in a comedic light.
Then again, perhaps you mean SD Gundam Force, which is an entirely different series all together and was actually tolerable compared to other Gundam shows out there (it had a much more coherent and unique plot than Ms igLoo, for example), albeit insanely low-budget and just plain marketed to the wrong crowd in America (the tone, the pastels, the themes - it was meant for early-morning children's programming).

But considering that, it makes me wonder if you've only seen the ones aired in America.
If so, then... really... you've not seen the worst of the worst. How one can rank Wing below Seed Destiny, Victory or Ms igLoo is far beyond my understanding.

[milhaus007]

I liked both series but if I have to choose one, it be G GUNDAM.

SHINING FINGER FTW :nuts


http://i253.photobucket.com/albums/hh79/milhaus007/Shining_Finger___Ala_Bush__by_Nydyn.jpg

[Wuzzman]

gundam wing.....fail wing? emo wing? too-gay for my shirt wing? Come on ANY series is better then gundam wing god damnit, that series was barely watchable, it's the gundamn for the kids who never watched a real gundamn series (and seed sure as fuck isn't real gundamn series just looks better then fucking wing....).

[GsG]

xHSSDFBQ2Co

*claps*

G Gundam wins. God Finger!

[NewtypeS3]

gundam wing.....fail wing? emo wing? too-gay for my shirt wing? Come on ANY series is better then gundam wing god damnit, that series was barely watchable, it's the gundamn for the kids who never watched a real gundamn series (and seed sure as fuck isn't real gundamn series just looks better then fucking wing....).

Why hello, another-troll-who-never-watched-Wing-and-only-remembers-stereotypes-that-have-no-bearing-on-the-series-at-all. And how are you today?

[Wuzzman]

I watched every episode, didn't the whole series end with the colonies vs the AI earth army (or was it the otherway around? who cares more shit blow up, a person who shouldn't have died lost to the asian boy....). A series like gundam wing would get at least a 7/10 if it wasn't for the emo warriors....Duo is the only believeable character in the whole series. When Hero (or however you want to spell his dumb name) decided to blow up his gundam I was like "YES THE *** IS DEAD!!!", when I found out he was still alive....weak story, plot twist that no one above the age of 14 would findd remarkable. I mean seriously giant space battle with AI robots? meh, at least shit blow up which is all the series really has to offer. I didn't watch G Gundam, mainly because it sounds over the top and ridiculous (shining finger...), but it is by no way a show even remotely watchable to a grown man, unless your expecting it to be god damn awful and you want to see something blow up and nothing else...sure Gundam Wing is a show that is brainless fun that tries to have a brain but doesn't seem to know how to spell brain.

[NewtypeS3]

I watched every episode,
Had you actually paid attention to those episodes, you wouldn't be throwing around generalizations that have nothing to do with the series.
The term 'emo' doesn't apply to any of the characters in Wing, seeing how none of them are actually suicidal, no one is morbidly obscessed with pain, none of the characters 'angst' during actual animated moments in the series... hell, the term 'emo' doesn't even remotely apply. But because the stereotype has been applied to every living thing in existence by now, Wing must be emo!
And 'gay'? Wow, a fantastic insult... had any character in the series shown anything remotely like homosexual tendencies. Even the most-assumed pairing of Trowa and Quatre didn't even hint at anything more than a close friendship!

Like I said, had you paid attention to Wing...


didn't the whole series end with the colonies vs the AI earth army (or was it the otherway around?
Other way around.
I can't help but laugh - something tells me you've not seen Wing since it was last shown on Toonami back in 2002... 6 years ago at this point. This, of course, means that what few things you did remember have been distorted and changed by the mere status of memory being an ever-changing and intangible thing

who cares more shit blow up, a person who shouldn't have died lost to the asian boy....).
And the fact that you don't remember names further adds to this. I'm assuming you mean Treize, who lost to Wufei in actual combat. Because he didn't lose on purpose, but because Wufei was far more skilled than him (just working with horrid melee weaponry compared to the saber of the Tallgeese II)

Duo is the only believeable character in the whole series.
Duo might be my own personal favorite character for Wing, but... the rest of the cast is also pretty believable in their own ways.

When Hero (or however you want to spell his dumb name)
Heero.
It's Japanese anime, where we get either Japanese names (in the case of Heero Yuy) or names that make no sense (Fllay and Ssigh, for example).

decided to blow up his gundam I was like "YES THE *** IS DEAD!!!", when I found out he was still alive....weak story, plot twist that no one above the age of 14 would found remarkable.
...the fact that Heero was in a coma for a month and still had major injuries he had yet to recover from several weeks after he'd re-awakened was 'weak' and 'an obvious plot twist'?
Well, God forbid you ever watch another Gundam show, considering the entire franchise is aimed at a young age market. Hence the teenaged main characters piloting gigantic weapons of war, hence the enemy often being adults, hence the entire franchise recycling concepts that work well with the young.

I mean seriously giant space battle with AI robots?
Considering that a vast percentage of America's military forces use unmanned drones and robots - something that Wing itself made a point in it's themes. The Predator unmanned scout plane, for example, is completely autonomous - much like the mobile dolls in Wing.
The theme argued was that war without mankind fighting and making the decisions was nothing more than a game, as shown by Romefeller's views on using their mobile dolls to stampede over the entire Earth.

But that'd require paying attention to the series.

meh, at least shit blow up which is all the series really has to offer.
Then, as I said before, God forbid you watch another Gundam series with similar themes, such as Gundam 00 or Gundam X.

I didn't watch G Gundam,
Then you're doing nothing but trolling.
Congrats.

mainly because it sounds over the top and ridiculous (shining finger...), but it is by no way a show even remotely watchable to a grown man, unless your expecting it to be god damn awful and you want to see something blow up and nothing else...
So, because you've never seen G-Gundam, it has to be unwatchable by a grown male?
Fantastic logic.

sure Gundam Wing is a show that is brainless fun that tries to have a brain but doesn't seem to know how to spell brain.
Except the themes are actually relevant to the modern day, more so than they were in 1995 when the series was made - unlike the Universal Century's theme of 'super magical Newtype HAX.'
But hey, you don't care. You just know that Wing is somehow bad because of vague memories of something similar.

[Byakuya]

Gundam Wing.

[Biolink]

Which reminds me.

What a drastic departure 00 is taking by making the entire main cast over 20 years old.

That would only leave Feltd as the only Teenage character left, even she is 19 years old. They could make her 20 if they wanted.

[Cloud]

Wing was cool. Then again, the Shiiinnnniiiiinnggg fiiinnnnggaaaaa is pretty epic..idk

All I know is that 00 puts them in their rightful place.

[Wuzzman]

Had you actually paid attention to those episodes, you wouldn't be throwing around generalizations that have nothing to do with the series.
The term 'emo' doesn't apply to any of the characters in Wing, seeing how none of them are actually suicidal, no one is morbidly obscessed with pain, none of the characters 'angst' during actual animated moments in the series... hell, the term 'emo' doesn't even remotely apply. But because the stereotype has been applied to every living thing in existence by now, Wing must be emo!
And 'gay'? Wow, a fantastic insult... had any character in the series shown anything remotely like homosexual tendencies. Even the most-assumed pairing of Trowa and Quatre didn't even hint at anything more than a close friendship!

I wish there was this much dedication to the definition of emo and gay when the name Sasuke comes up. Didn't whats his name attempt to kill himself (and sadly didn't manage to do so). Their angst pisses me off, no grown man would be convinced that a bunch of 14 year olds are solo'ing military bases, let alone doing so while lacking a proper dick and a pair of balls.

Like I said, had you paid attention to Wing...

If there was something to pay attention to....

Other way around.
I can't help but laugh - something tells me you've not seen Wing since it was last shown on Toonami back in 2002... 6 years ago at this point. This, of course, means that what few things you did remember have been distorted and changed by the mere status of memory being an ever-changing and intangible thing

...anywho the plot is not memorable, I never cared for the "plot twist" that gundam wing throws around so much no one with a brain would actually still care.


And the fact that you don't remember names further adds to this. I'm assuming you mean Treize, who lost to Wufei in actual combat. Because he didn't lose on purpose, but because Wufei was far more skilled than him (just working with horrid melee weaponry compared to the saber of the Tallgeese II)

That was the best fight in the series if I remember, Wufei won because he got a new UBER gundam.....Treize has far more skilled then Wufei, I called BS on the entire ending on that one, if Treize is going to lose, fine, but why the fuck kill one of the few characters that have a pair?

Duo might be my own personal favorite character for Wing, but... the rest of the cast is also pretty believable in their own ways.

:rotfl:rotfl:rotfl:rotfl:rotfl
Heero.
It's Japanese anime, where we get either Japanese names (in the case of Heero Yuy) or names that make no sense (Fllay and Ssigh, for example).


...the fact that Heero was in a coma for a month and still had major injuries he had yet to recover from several weeks after he'd re-awakened was 'weak' and 'an obvious plot twist'?
Well, God forbid you ever watch another Gundam show, considering the entire franchise is aimed at a young age market. Hence the teenaged main characters piloting gigantic weapons of war, hence the enemy often being adults, hence the entire franchise recycling concepts that work well with the young.

I'm not 14, and if I was 14, trained to be the uber assassin, I would think i have more balls then emo boy. Now what show sucked again...oh this one

Considering that a vast percentage of America's military forces use unmanned drones and robots - something that Wing itself made a point in it's themes. The Predator unmanned scout plane, for example, is completely autonomous - much like the mobile dolls in Wing.
The theme argued was that war without mankind fighting and making the decisions was nothing more than a game, as shown by Romefeller's views on using their mobile dolls to stampede over the entire Earth.

hmm yeah giant space battle with AI gundam woot woot, woot woot. Basically it went from fodder humans to fodder pieces of metal, at least there isn't a grown man in the cockpit getting owned by some 14 year old kid.

But that'd require paying attention to the series.


Then, as I said before, God forbid you watch another Gundam series with similar themes, such as Gundam 00 or Gundam X.



Then you're doing nothing but trolling.
Congrats.


So, because you've never seen G-Gundam, it has to be unwatchable by a grown male?
Fantastic logic.

I wasn't referring to G Gundam I was talking about Wing(which is very much unwatchable) .

Except the themes are actually relevant to the modern day, more so than they were in 1995 when the series was made - unlike the Universal Century's theme of 'super magical Newtype HAX.'
But hey, you don't care. You just know that Wing is somehow bad because of vague memories of something similar.

Did you just say that G Gundam is part of the UC Gundam verse....


I say this once and I say it again gundam wing is gundam for the kids who never watched or read a UC gundam series (and I may have to say the crap that came after Wing is the same...). Now I'm sure from your G-Gundam = UC comment you probably very confused or you simply don't know what your talking about, probably because you was busy watching Gundam Wing....any who you can look up the real Universal Century on wikipedia; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Century; or you can look up episodes on youtube.

Lol the Gundam 00 the first gundam series that have characters over the age of 20...wow more like first Gundam since Wing....

[Red Zaku]

I say this once and I say it again gundam wing is gundam for the kids who never watched or read a UC gundam series (and I may have to say the crap that came after Wing is the same...)

Well, then G-Gundam came before Wing so your logic sucks. But then having an opinion thankfully doesn't make you right, and in this case it makes you seem like an elitist ass. >.> But hey, we can't all be sensible people.

Now I'm sure from your G-Gundam = UC comment you probably very confused or you simply don't know what your talking about,

The guy who just claimed the concepts of soldiers honor, war losing meaning without humans, and the paradox of peace being maintained with force, are kid themes is now talking about confusion? >.> Wow. Never thought I'd see the day.

probably because you was busy watching Gundam Wing....

Ok, not to be a grammar nazi or anything but you use the phrase, "because you was," and you're trying to insult someone else's intelligence? I wonder does the concept of irony enter your mind at any point while you were typing this?

any who you can look up the real Universal Century on wikipedia;http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Century;[/url]

>.> Lol. Wikipedia. Need I say more?

Lol the Gundam 00 the first gundam series that have characters over the age of 20...wow more like first Gundam since Wing

>.>
UC series Main characters:
Amuro....15
Al.........11
Bernie....19
Kou.......19
Kamille...17
Judau....14
Seabook.16/17
Uso...... 13

>.> UC gundam series main characters are never above the age of 20. The only time they've ever been over 18 is for the short movie and OVA side stories. I guess fact checking isn't one of your strong points?

[Narcissus]

G Gundam was shit. Gundam Wing wins this easily. Please.