PDA

View Full Version : Character Discussion - Mion/Shion


BakaOnna
11-11-2007, 04:02 PM
I know, I know, why did I put the twins together? Well... cuz I felt like it. :P Nah, it's because it'll give me an easier way of explaining this.

Mion/Shion Relevation (prepare for more epic mindf**k if you haven't already found this out. And yes, this was left out in the anime):
At the end of Meakashi-hen, we finally know that Shion is the one behind everything. In reality, the character we know as Mion (the one since the 1st arc and so on) is actually the original Shion, while the one we know as Shion (who we meet in the 2nd arc) is actually the original Mion. Confusing much? Here's what happened:

The twin we know as "Mion" was actually borned second after the twin known as "Shion". Both twins felt it was unfair with the way the whole Sonozaki family was set up, and how it was always being ratted down so they switch places, much like shown in the anime. One day when Shion (the one we know as Mion) was pretending to be Mion, she was mistaken and given the demon seal/tatoo to signify her as the head of the Sonozaki household. Thus, the girls became their wrong idenities, and the original Mion (we know as Shion) is left with the curse of being an outsider, and the one that goes crazy in Watangashi-hen and Meakashi-hen. Over time, however, since they are constantly in their "roles", they've forgotten who they really were, meaning the real Shion became who we know as "Mion", and the real Mion became who we know as "Shion".

This fact will is presented slightly two TIPS since the "Shion" we know refers to herself as Mion and view her sister as Shion.

But first, here's some extra info on the history of the (very messed up) Sonozaki family:
About the Sonozaki House; back before the Meiji Restoration, Himinazawa was renknown as a respected village because the people there were allegedly descended from demons. But, with Mutsuhito's rise and an ushering in of the "future", the old ways were condemened, and the people of Himinazawa, then Onifaguchi, were discriminated against. Eventually, anti-discrimination laws were passed that bettered the people's name, and, during World War II, reknown would be restored to the town because Mion's grandfather, a food supplier, managed to manufacture canned food cheaply enough to feed overseas troops.

However, Himinazawa was descriminated yet again when allegations of using dead humans in the meat on the front lines was brought up against Mion's grandfather. He denied these claims until he died; then, Oryou Sonozaki took over command of the town and made a pact; Himinazawa would stick together to fight discrimination. If one person was beaten up, the town would band together and beat up whoever assaulted the townsmember. If someone threw rocks, everyone would throw rocks back. And so the Sonozaki House became legendary for bringing Himinazawa back to its feet.

Oh, one more thing; remember the nail-ripping ritual? Mion/Shion's mother endured the same torture because she married "a wrong kind of man" and had to receive a pardon. In turn, Oryou herself went through the same punishment as a little girl.

Sick irony, eh?

There you go. Now you know why. So post your opinions, views, thoughts, questions, concens, whatever's on your mind about the Sonozaki twins.

Oh, and for the sake of less confusion, just stick with their anime names. :P

Paul the SK
11-11-2007, 04:44 PM
That reading was proabably atleast 10x more confusing that how they explained it in the anime (which I actualy understood).

BakaOnna
11-11-2007, 05:01 PM
That reading was proabably atleast 10x more confusing that how they explained it in the anime (which I actualy understood).
That wasn't explained in the anime. The anime never even touched on it (which I'm kinda glad they didn't.) Basically, the Mion we know of (the tomboyish one that likes Keiichi) is actually Shion, and the Shion we know of (that goes crazy and likes Satoshi) is Mion. The rest goes as I explained in my first post.

Here, maybe these TIPS will sort of explain things (these TIPS take place at the end of Meakashi-hen): Epilogue A (http://forums.animesuki.com/showpost.php?p=655789&postcount=109)
Epilogue B (http://forums.animesuki.com/showpost.php?p=655798&postcount=110)
Epilogue C (http://forums.animesuki.com/showpost.php?p=656438&postcount=111)
Shion's Dream/Final Note (http://forums.animesuki.com/showpost.php?p=656514&postcount=112)

Paul the SK
11-11-2007, 05:03 PM
Mion is Mion and Shion is Shion. :sag

I'm personaly just going to go with the anime's canon.

Clouds-Are-Nice
11-11-2007, 05:14 PM
*reads spoiler*

...:huh...
...:huh...
...:huh...

...I think it'll take a while for my brain to process this...

QBnoYouko
11-11-2007, 05:51 PM
You guys take a while huh? It certainly makes some sense now. But I don't think the names are what matters anyway, it's the character.

With that said, the Sonozaki twins are awesome characters. Watanagashi-hen and Meakashi-hen proved that much. It's because of them I began to respect Satsuki Yukino ever more for distinguishing between the voices extremely well, even through song.

MarthX7
11-11-2007, 06:08 PM
Mion (birth name Shion): loves Keiichi, has the demon tattoo, is the Sonozaki heir, is the club leader

She was originally Shion, the outcast of the Sonozakis. She got the demon tattoo by accident instead of her sister. She feels bad about it for taking her life.


Shion (birth name Mion): loves Satoshi, carries a tazer, is the outcast of the Sonozakis

She was originally Mion, she was supposed to be the Sonozaki heir. But one day while they swapped places, her sister got the demon tattoo instead of her. They were unable to reverse the situation so Mion became Shion.

Clouds-Are-Nice
11-11-2007, 06:15 PM
Mion (birth name Shion): loves Keiichi, has the demon tattoo, is the Sonozaki heir, is the club leader

She was originally Shion, the outcast of the Sonozakis. She got the demon tattoo by accident instead of her sister. She feels bad about it for taking her life.


Shion (birth name Mion): loves Satoshi, carries a tazer, the outcast of the Sonozakis

She was originally Mion, she was supposed to be the Sonozaki heir. But one day while they swapped places, her sister got the demon tattoo instead of her. They were unable to reverse the situation so Mion became Shion.


So that means in Watanagashi-hen, the tattooed Shmion that killed everyone was the one we knew as 'Mion' for the first arc?

MarthX7
11-11-2007, 06:19 PM
So that means in Watanagashi-hen, the tattooed Shmion that killed everyone was the one we knew as 'Mion' for the first arc?

No. She never showed the tattoo because she didn't have it. The one we know as Mion is innocent and doesn't kill anyone. The one we know as Shion can go crazy and kill several people.

Shion's talk about having a demon in her is referring to her jealousy and hatred that's motivating her to do all these things.

The Mion in Onikakushi was Mion. Shion was never shown but she was at Angel Mort and saw Keiichi there. That's why Mion knew he was there with Ooishi.

Clouds-Are-Nice
11-11-2007, 06:22 PM
No. She never showed the tattoo because she didn't have it. The one we know as Mion is innocent and doesn't kill anyone. The one we know as Shion can go crazy and kill several people.

Shion's talk about having a demon in her is referring to her jealousy and hatred that's motivating her to do all these things.

Thanks for the explanation, Shion\Mion makes sense to me now. :amuse

G@R-chan
11-24-2007, 06:41 AM
My favourite twins in Higurashi.:nuts

I like a lot both characters, I only considered Shion before seeing Mion a lot more in the second season. I love her face when she's having club activities, and the overall things she's doing to help everyone.
Shion is the cute one, definitely hooked me up the first time she appeared at Angel mort. Even when she goes batshit crazy is fascinating.:awesome

Rob_Zero
11-24-2007, 07:01 AM
Let's see.

Shion. Feminine, motherly to Satoko and occasionally homicidally psychotic. Wears her hair down with a ribbon tied to the back.

Mion. Demon tattooed, masculine and refers to herself as a middle-aged man (oji-san). Wears her hair in a ponytail.

Satsuki Yukino definitely does a great job doing the both of them, as I'm very capable of telling who's who from voice alone. Personally, I prefer Mion out of the two. She's funnier, and I share in Kyon's (from Haruhi) view, ponytails turn me on.

Souten Kishun
11-26-2007, 07:00 AM
Mion (birth name Shion): loves Keiichi, has the demon tattoo, is the Sonozaki heir, is the club leader

She was originally Shion, the outcast of the Sonozakis. She got the demon tattoo by accident instead of her sister. She feels bad about it for taking her life.


Shion (birth name Mion): loves Satoshi, carries a tazer, is the outcast of the Sonozakis

She was originally Mion, she was supposed to be the Sonozaki heir. But one day while they swapped places, her sister got the demon tattoo instead of her. They were unable to reverse the situation so Mion became Shion.

Ha! :nuts Wow that's awesome

Let's see.

Shion. Feminine, motherly to Satoko and occasionally homicidally psychotic. Wears her hair down with a ribbon tied to the back.

Mion. Demon tattooed, masculine and refers to herself as a middle-aged man (oji-san). Wears her hair in a ponytail.

Satsuki Yukino definitely does a great job doing the both of them, as I'm very capable of telling who's who from voice alone. Personally, I prefer Mion out of the two. She's funnier, and I share in Kyon's (from Haruhi) view, ponytails turn me on.

Heck yeah, agreed.

Meakashi-hen solidified who my favorite sister was :3 Plus Mion x K is a pairing made from GAR.

Agmaster
11-29-2007, 01:19 PM
The Mion in Onikakushi was Mion. Shion was never shown but she was at Angel Mort and saw Keiichi there. That's why Mion knew he was there with Ooishi.

Oh SNAP! I forgot about that! Man, this is a headache.