the fight of all ages

[luxjason]

who would win in a fight luffie or the pirate king?

[sephirous]

The Pirate King, of course! I mean, the hero cannot always win. He will probably lose, train harder, and beat the Pirate King the second time... or something... :kkbook

Oh, I need a new siggy...

Well, bye!

[Molekage]

^... don't... triple... post...

at this point in time, roger > luffy.

[Sawako]

Right now, Gol D. Roger > Monkey D. Luffy.

Luff might surpass him some day.

[Moondoggie]

For story purposes I would say Roger.
But then again we really don't know his strength yet, but only that he was strong.{And first to Whitebeard}

[Molekage]

if ace is under whitebeard, and ace could beat luffy without the devil fruit ability, and roger was above whitebeard... and assuming linear strength then luffy isn't as good as roger

[Moondoggie]

if ace is under whitebeard, and ace could beat luffy without the devil fruit ability, and roger was above whitebeard... and assuming linear strength then luffy isn't as good as roger

That's very true, all logic leads to Roger>WhiteBeard>Ace>Luffy>Ace.
This makes me want to see a rematch between Ace and Luffy to see after all this time if Luffy can beat him now. I guess I will just have to wait till the SHs make it to Pirate's Summit. heh

[Segan]

Well, if he's able to beat the strongest Assassin of the World Government, then Luffy should be at least equal to Ace...

But the fire element is a tough one to fight against for Luffy...

[Molekage]

i personally don't think ace would have had a problem against cp9 either @_@

but luffy is clearly moving up in rank. hes on part with the world government's most powerful marines.